Firsthand QC
Pre-Shipment Inspection Report
FAILMajor defects over the acceptance limit
Key findings
- 9 major defects in 125 samples, against an acceptance limit of 7. Five are coating chips at the base edge.
- 1 unit lost its vacuum: outer wall at 41 °C after a hot fill (unit #88).
- Coating adhesion below spec on 1 of 5 tested units (3B against ≥4B), at the same base edge where chips were found.
1. Order and inspection details
| Client | Sample Brand Co. (illustrative) |
| Product | 500 ml double-wall vacuum bottle, 18/8 stainless steel, powder-coated, screw lid with silicone gasket |
| Item no. / PO no. | SB-500 / SAMPLE-PO-0001 |
| Order quantity | 3,000 pcs (3 colours × 1,000) |
| Status at inspection | 100% produced, 85% packed. 120 export cartons of 25 pcs. |
| Factory location | Yongkang, Zhejiang, China (name withheld in sample) |
| Inspection type | Pre-shipment inspection (final random inspection) |
| Reference documents | Client spec sheet v2, approved golden sample, packing list |
2. Sampling plan
| Standard | Level | Lot size | Code | Sample size | Critical | Major AQL 2.5 | Minor AQL 4.0 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ISO 2859-1, single sampling, normal | General II | 3,000 | K | 125 | Ac 0 / Re 1 | Ac 7 / Re 8 | Ac 10 / Re 11 |
Cartons for sampling were selected at random by the inspector from all stacks. Function tests used a sub-sample agreed with the client (13 pcs, 5 pcs for destructive tests).
3. Results by section
| Section | Result | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Quantity and packing list | PASS | 120 cartons counted, matches packing list. |
| Packing, carton marks, barcodes | PASS | 10 of 10 barcodes scanned and readable. Carton marks match spec. |
| Workmanship (visual), 125 pcs | FAIL | 8 major and 6 minor visual defects. See section 4. |
| Function tests, 13 pcs | FAIL | 1 vacuum failure (major). See section 5. |
| Coating adhesion, 5 pcs | FAIL | 1 of 5 at 3B, requirement ≥4B. |
| Capacity, size and weight, 5 pcs | PASS | All within spec tolerance. |
| Food-contact documents | INFO | Factory showed a third-party test report for the steel and lid materials. Sighted only, not verified with the lab. |
4. Defects found
| # | Defect | Class | Qty | Photo |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Coating chip at base edge, 1 mm or larger, steel visible | Major | 5 | P1–P3 |
| 2 | Lid gasket not fully seated in its groove | Major | 2 | P4 |
| 3 | Dent on body, 2 mm or larger | Major | 1 | P5 |
| 4 | Lost vacuum: outer wall warm after hot fill (from function tests) | Major | 1 | P6 |
| 5 | Light surface scratch on body, under 10 mm | Minor | 3 | P7 |
| 6 | Logo print off-centre by 1–2 mm | Minor | 2 | P8 |
| 7 | Dust inside gift box | Minor | 1 | — |
| Class | Found | Accept / Reject | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Critical (unsafe, e.g. sharp edge) | 0 | 0 / 1 | PASS |
| Major | 9 | 7 / 8 | FAIL |
| Minor | 6 | 10 / 11 | PASS |
5. Function and on-site tests
| Test | Method | Requirement | Qty | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Heat retention | Pre-heat, fill with 95 °C water, close lid, room at 23 °C, read at 6 h | ≥ 60 °C at 6 h (client spec) | 13 | 13/13 64–69 °C |
| Vacuum check | Fill with 95 °C water, wait 10 min, IR thermometer on outer wall | Outer wall ≤ room temp + 3 °C | 13 | 12/13 Unit #88 at 41 °C |
| Leak test | Fill to the brim, close lid, hold upside down on paper for 30 min | No leak, no damp paper | 13 | 13/13 |
| Coating adhesion | Cross-hatch tape test, ASTM D3359 Method B, at base edge | ≥ 4B | 5 | 4/5 One at 3B |
| Capacity | Fill to brim, weigh the water | 500 ml, −0 / +5% | 5 | 5/5 512–518 ml |
| Lid fit | Open and close 10 times, check thread and gasket | Smooth, no cross-threading | 13 | 13/13 |
| Odour | Hot rinse, close for 10 min, smell | No abnormal odour | 13 | 13/13 |
| Carton drop | ISTA 1A drop sequence from 76 cm, 10 drops | No product damage | 1 ctn | PASS |
6. Recommendation
- Do not ship this lot as is.
- Factory to sort 100% for base-edge coating chips and re-seat any loose gaskets. Units that fail the vacuum check must be removed.
- Re-inspect the sorted lot before release.
- Chips and the low adhesion result are both at the base edge, which points to coating adhesion rather than handling damage. Ask the factory to check surface pre-treatment and curing for the base edge before the next lot.
7. Factory record
| Lot | Date | Sample | Major defects | Major rate | Main issue | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lot 1 (this report) | Sample | 125 | 9 | 7.2% | Base-edge coating chips | FAIL |
| Lot 2 | — | — | — | — | Added after the next inspection | — |
Each factory keeps one running record, so you can see whether the same problem comes back and whether fixes hold.
8. Photo evidence
P1 · Base-edge chip, 1.5 mm, unit #47
P2 · Base-edge chip, unit #63
P3 · Chip close-up with ruler
P4 · Gasket out of groove
P5 · Body dent, 2.5 mm
P6 · IR reading 41 °C, unit #88
P7 · Surface scratch
P8 · Logo offset vs golden sample
Photos are omitted in this sample. Real reports include a photo or short video for every defect and every test.
Results apply only to the samples inspected on the date stated and do not release the factory from its obligations to the client.
Firsthand QC is an independent inspection service, paid only by the client. · firsthandqc.com · [email protected] · Hangzhou, Zhejiang, China